28 Best Magic: The Gathering Gifts for MTG Players

Magic: The Gathering gifts for new and veteran players: Commander decks, booster boxes, Dragon Shield sleeves, deck boxes, playmats and a binder.

Updated 28 gifts curated $11.28 โ€“ $194.95

Buying for a Magic: The Gathering player can feel risky. Magic has thousands of cards, several formats and new sets every few months, and the player in your life probably has opinions about all of it. The good news is that some gifts are always welcome: sealed product they can open, accessories they wear out and storage for a collection that never stops growing.

We built this list of 28 Magic: The Gathering gifts with that in mind. It starts with sealed product, from a $20 Final Fantasy Starter Kit to Commander decks and full booster boxes from the Star Trek and Avatar: The Last Airbender sets. Then come the accessories that serious players go through: Dragon Shield sleeves, hard deck boxes, a zip binder, life counters and a playmat. We finish with books, apparel and a puzzle for fans who love the art and lore. We left out single cards, because prices change daily and you risk buying one they already own.

Editor's Top Picks

The best gifts for magic the gathering lovers

Hand-picked by our editorial team from 28 options we researched.

#1 Pick
MTG Star Trek Commander Deck: Federation Fleet

MTG Star Trek Commander Deck: Federation Fleet

$58

Why we love it:100-card deck ready to play

#2 Pick
MTG Avatar: The Last Airbender Beginner Box

MTG Avatar: The Last Airbender Beginner Box

$28.98

Why we love it:Step-by-step tutorial decks

#3 Pick
Dragon Shield Matte Sleeves, 100 Count

Dragon Shield Matte Sleeves, 100 Count

$11.28

Why we love it:Smooth matte shuffle feel

Buyer's Guide

How to pick the best magic: the gathering gifts

Ask which format they play. Most casual groups play Commander, a 100-card multiplayer format. If they mention Commander, a preconstructed Commander deck or a 100-card deck box is a safe bet. If they go to drafts or prereleases at a game store, booster boxes are the better gift.

Match the Universes Beyond set to their other fandoms. Magic now releases sets based on Final Fantasy, Star Trek, Avatar: The Last Airbender, Spider-Man and Fallout. A Trekkie who plays Magic will be thrilled with the Federation Fleet Commander deck, even if they skipped the latest regular set.

Accessories are consumable. Sleeves split, deck boxes crack and playmats wear out. A pack of Dragon Shield matte sleeves or a Boulder deck box is never a wasted gift, and it is a good choice if you are unsure what cards they already own.

Starting someone new? Buy a two-player product such as the Avatar Beginner Box or the Final Fantasy Starter Kit, so the recipient has someone to play with straight away. The Foundations Commander bundle does the same for a group of four or five.

Collector or player? Collectors care about foils, alternate art and condition. For them, look at the Collector Booster, the Secret Lair drop, toploaders and the graded card wall display rather than playable decks.

Shop by Budget

Our best pick at every price point

Under $25 (15) $25โ€“$50 (5) $50โ€“$100 (5) Over $100 (3)

MTG Booster Boxes, Commander Decks and Collector Packs

Sealed product for experienced players: booster boxes to draft, ready-to-play Commander decks and premium collector packs.

MTG Avatar: The Last Airbender Play Booster Box - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$129.99epic

A sealed booster box is the dream gift for an MTG player, and Avatar: The Last Airbender is one of the most popular crossover sets so far. Thirty packs is enough to host a draft night with friends or to chase every bender they want for a new deck.

Why MTG Avatar: The Last Airbender Play Booster Box makes a epic gift:

  • โœ“30 Play Booster packs
  • โœ“Iconic Avatar characters and scenes
  • โœ“Draftable straight from the box
MTG Star Trek Commander Deck: Federation Fleet - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$58ready-to-play

Commander decks are the easiest Magic gift to get right because they play straight out of the box. This one is led by Jean-Luc Picard with 33 new Star Trek cards, so it is perfect for a Commander player who has a soft spot for Starfleet.

Why MTG Star Trek Commander Deck: Federation Fleet makes a ready-to-play gift:

  • โœ“100-card deck ready to play
  • โœ“33 new Star Trek cards
  • โœ“Built for multiplayer Commander
MTG Star Trek Play Booster Box - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$109bold

Pair this with the Federation Fleet deck for the ultimate Trekkie gift, or give it alone to a player who loves opening packs. Every booster has a foil and at least one rare, so each pack holds a chance at something good.

Why MTG Star Trek Play Booster Box makes a bold gift:

  • โœ“30 Play Booster packs
  • โœ“Foil in every pack
  • โœ“Draftable straight from the box
MTG Final Fantasy XIV Commander Deck - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$59.69beautiful

For someone who has logged hundreds of hours in Final Fantasy XIV, this deck is pure fan service: every card carries new FFXIV art, with Y'shtola leading a spell-slinging strategy. It suits a player who likes control and card draw over big creatures.

Why MTG Final Fantasy XIV Commander Deck makes a beautiful gift:

  • โœ“New FFXIV art on all 100 cards
  • โœ“25 new Commander cards
  • โœ“Spell-focused strategy
MTG Secrets of Strixhaven Collector Booster - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$57.93thrilling

A single Collector Booster is the stocking-sized splurge for a collector. It packs several rares and foils plus Mystical Archive spells, so opening it on Christmas morning feels like an event.

Why MTG Secrets of Strixhaven Collector Booster makes a thrilling gift:

  • โœ“Multiple rares and foils per pack
  • โœ“Mystical Archive cards included
  • โœ“Premium special-treatment cards
MTG Secret Lair x Fallout: New Vegas - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$77.43limited

Secret Lair drops are printed for a limited time, which makes them a collector's favorite. This all-foil set turns Magic cards into New Vegas characters, a great fit for someone who loves Fallout as much as Commander.

Why MTG Secret Lair x Fallout: New Vegas makes a limited gift:

  • โœ“Limited Secret Lair drop
  • โœ“All-foil cards
  • โœ“Fallout: New Vegas artwork

Magic: The Gathering Gifts for Beginners

Boxed sets that teach the game and include enough cards for two to five people to start playing together.

MTG Avatar: The Last Airbender Beginner Box - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$28.98welcoming

This is the gift to bring a new player into the game, especially one who grew up with Aang and Zuko. Tutorial decks walk two people through their first match, and the half-decks let them build new combos once they get the hang of it.

Why MTG Avatar: The Last Airbender Beginner Box makes a welcoming gift:

  • โœ“Step-by-step tutorial decks
  • โœ“Eight mix-and-match half-decks
  • โœ“Playboards and spindowns included
MTG Final Fantasy Starter Kit - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$19.83affordable

Two ready-made 60-card decks for around $20 make this the cheapest way to start playing Magic with a friend. Final Fantasy fans will recognize the characters, which makes learning the rules much more fun.

Why MTG Final Fantasy Starter Kit makes a affordable gift:

  • โœ“Two 60-card decks
  • โœ“Learn-to-play guide
  • โœ“Final Fantasy characters and art
MTG Foundations Commander Deck Bundle - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$194.95generous

All five Foundations Commander decks in one bundle is a gift for a whole family or friend group. Everyone picks a deck, from angels to dinosaurs, and you can play your first four- or five-player Commander game that evening.

Why MTG Foundations Commander Deck Bundle makes a generous gift:

  • โœ“Five 100-card decks
  • โœ“Enough for a full Commander pod
  • โœ“Beginner-friendly decks

MTG Card Sleeves, Deck Boxes and Storage

The protection and organization every growing collection needs, from sleeves and toploaders to binders and a wall display.

Dragon Shield Matte Sleeves, 100 Count - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$11.28essential

Ask any Magic player which sleeves they use and many will say Dragon Shield matte. A pack of 100 covers a full Commander deck, they shuffle smoothly and they are cheap enough to be a stocking stuffer. This pack is black, the color that suits any deck and hides wear best.

Why Dragon Shield Matte Sleeves, 100 Count makes a essential gift:

  • โœ“Smooth matte shuffle feel
  • โœ“Tough, split-resistant sleeves
  • โœ“Fits standard 63 x 88 mm cards
Ultimate Guard Boulder 100+ Deck Box - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$18.76sturdy

The Boulder is the hard plastic deck box you see at every game store. It fits a sleeved Commander deck perfectly and survives being thrown in a backpack, which the cardboard box from the store will not.

Why Ultimate Guard Boulder 100+ Deck Box makes a sturdy gift:

  • โœ“Fits 100 double-sleeved cards
  • โœ“Snug, secure lid
  • โœ“Durable rigid shell
Gamegenic Squire 100+ XL Deck Box - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$15.79roomy

If they always carry tokens and dice with their deck, the Squire XL has room for both. The lid clips to the bottom during play, which matters to a Commander player who has already lost a few lids under the table.

Why Gamegenic Squire 100+ XL Deck Box makes a roomy gift:

  • โœ“Extra space for tokens
  • โœ“Removable lid clips to the base
  • โœ“Holds a sleeved Commander deck
Vault X 9-Pocket Zip Card Binder - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$29.99protective

Every player has a trade binder or a stack of rares that needs a home. This padded binder zips shut and holds 360 cards in side-loading pockets, so nothing slides out on the way to the game store.

Why Vault X 9-Pocket Zip Card Binder makes a protective gift:

  • โœ“Holds 360 cards
  • โœ“Side-loading pockets
  • โœ“Zipper and water-resistant cover
Ultra Pro Toploaders & Sleeves, 200 Pack - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$25.99practical

Toploaders are the unglamorous supply every collector runs short on. Two hundred of them mean every valuable pull and trade gets proper protection, which a collector will appreciate more than you might think.

Why Ultra Pro Toploaders & Sleeves, 200 Pack makes a practical gift:

  • โœ“Rigid toploaders plus sleeves
  • โœ“Fits standard cards up to 35pt
  • โœ“Enough for a growing collection
Woodhaven 3200-Count Card Storage Boxes - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$24.99spacious

After a few years of Magic, bulk commons end up in shoeboxes all over the house. These four-row boxes hold thousands of cards with dividers for each set or color, giving the collection a proper system.

Why Woodhaven 3200-Count Card Storage Boxes makes a spacious gift:

  • โœ“Holds 3,200 raw cards each
  • โœ“Built-in row dividers
  • โœ“Made in the USA
Storage Standard 15-Slot Sorting Tray - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$19.97organized

Anyone who opens a booster box knows the pain of sorting the cards afterward. This tray gives them 15 compartments to sort by color, rarity or deck, and it stacks out of the way when they are done.

Why Storage Standard 15-Slot Sorting Tray makes a organized gift:

  • โœ“15 compartments
  • โœ“Stackable
  • โœ“Fits raw, sleeved or toploaded cards
VERANI Graded Card Wall Display - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$54.99showcase

For the collector who has started grading cards, a lockable wall case is a gift they rarely buy themselves. The UV-blocking acrylic protects the slabs and turns their best pulls into a display for the game room.

Why VERANI Graded Card Wall Display makes a showcase gift:

  • โœ“Holds 35 graded slabs
  • โœ“UV-blocking acrylic panel
  • โœ“Lockable wood frame

MTG Playmats, Dice and Life Counters

Playmats, a carry tube, life counters and keyword dice that make every game smoother.

Ultra PRO Final Fantasy Double-Sided Playmat - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$18.25striking

A playmat protects cards on the table and announces a little personality at the game store. This double-sided Final Fantasy mat is a great match for anyone playing the Final Fantasy decks above.

Why Ultra PRO Final Fantasy Double-Sided Playmat makes a striking gift:

  • โœ“Officially licensed art
  • โœ“Double-sided design
  • โœ“Standard 24 x 13.5 inches
Easecos Playmat Tube Carry Case - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$22.99convenient

Rolled playmats tend to crease in a backpack. This tube carries one or two mats plus a deck and dice, so a weekly Friday Night Magic player has everything in one bag.

Why Easecos Playmat Tube Carry Case makes a convenient gift:

  • โœ“Holds 1-2 playmats
  • โœ“Deck and dice pockets
  • โœ“Adjustable shoulder strap
Brizago 84-Piece MTG Dice and Token Set - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$13.99colorful

Commander games involve a lot of counters, and this set includes dice for life, +1/+1 counters and keyword abilities like flying and deathtouch. It ends the confusion of using random coins as tokens.

Why Brizago 84-Piece MTG Dice and Token Set makes a colorful gift:

  • โœ“Keyword ability dice
  • โœ“Spindown life counter included
  • โœ“12 colors
NiToy Dial Life Counters, 5 Pack - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$11.99clever

Five dial counters mean every player in a Commander pod can track their own life total. They are small enough to live in a deck box, making them a cheap gift for the person who hosts game night.

Why NiToy Dial Life Counters, 5 Pack makes a clever gift:

  • โœ“Five counters, one per player
  • โœ“Double-digit dials
  • โœ“Compact and portable

Magic: The Gathering Books, Clothing and Fan Gifts

Cookbooks, comics, clothing and a puzzle for fans who love the art and lore as much as the game.

Magic: The Gathering Official Cookbook - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$26.34delicious

This cookbook turns lore from Ravnica, Innistrad and other planes into over 70 recipes. It is a fun gift for the friend who hosts Commander night and is tired of ordering pizza.

Why Magic: The Gathering Official Cookbook makes a delicious gift:

  • โœ“70+ lore-inspired recipes
  • โœ“Official licensed book
  • โœ“Great for game night
Official Magic: The Gathering Coloring Book - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$12.1relaxing

Magic's art is half the reason people fall for the game. This coloring book lets a fan spend a quiet evening with famous cards and characters, and it makes a cheap add-on to a bigger gift.

Why Official Magic: The Gathering Coloring Book makes a relaxing gift:

  • โœ“Official card art line drawings
  • โœ“Relaxing off-table hobby
  • โœ“Low price
Magic: The Gathering: Untold Stories - Elspeth - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$19.95story-rich

For the player who reads the story articles for every set, this Dark Horse graphic novel follows Elspeth, one of Magic's best-known planeswalkers. It is a good pick for a fan who enjoys the lore as much as the matches.

Why Magic: The Gathering: Untold Stories - Elspeth makes a story-rich gift:

  • โœ“Official Magic story
  • โœ“Focus on Elspeth
  • โœ“Graphic novel format
MTG Retro Fight Scene T-Shirt - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$16.99retro

An officially licensed shirt with old-school Magic battle art is something a player will happily wear to their next prerelease. Check their usual size before ordering.

Why MTG Retro Fight Scene T-Shirt makes a retro gift:

  • โœ“Officially licensed
  • โœ“Lightweight classic fit
  • โœ“Retro card art print
MTG Mana Symbols Knit Beanie - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$24.99subtle

The five mana symbols are instantly recognizable to other players and mysterious to everyone else. A beanie is a size-free, under-$25 gift for an MTG fan heading out on winter game nights.

Why MTG Mana Symbols Knit Beanie makes a subtle gift:

  • โœ“Five mana symbols design
  • โœ“One size fits most
  • โœ“Discreet logo tag
MTG Colors & Symbols Pullover Hoodie - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$37.39cozy

This hoodie lines up all five Magic colors with their mana symbols, so it suits any player whatever deck they prefer. It is a comfortable layer for long tournament days in chilly game stores.

Why MTG Colors & Symbols Pullover Hoodie makes a cozy gift:

  • โœ“Officially licensed
  • โœ“8.5 oz fleece
  • โœ“Five-color mana design
Magic: The Gathering Artifacts Puzzle - Magic: The Gathering Gifts
$17.97detailed

Covered in famous artifact card art, this 500-piece puzzle lets a fan spot cards they know as they build. It is a relaxed activity for a weekend off from games.

Why Magic: The Gathering Artifacts Puzzle makes a detailed gift:

  • โœ“500 pieces
  • โœ“Finished size 24 x 18 inches
  • โœ“Official Magic artwork

The best Magic: The Gathering gift is one that ends up on the table at the next game night, whether that is a fresh Commander deck, a new playmat or simply sleeves to protect the cards they already love. Pick one that fits how they play and you will hear about it the next time they win.

Shopping for a tabletop fan? See our board game gifts and Dungeons and Dragons gifts. For other collectors and gamers, try Pokemon gifts, gaming gifts and anime gifts.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best magic: the gathering gifts?

Our top picks include MTG Star Trek Commander Deck: Federation Fleet, MTG Avatar: The Last Airbender Beginner Box, Dragon Shield Matte Sleeves, 100 Count. We evaluated 28 products across categories like Booster Boxes & Commander Decks, For New Players, Sleeves, Deck Boxes & Storage.

How much should I spend on magic: the gathering gifts?

Gifts in our guide range from $11.28 to $194.95. We recommend budgeting $30โ€“$75 for a thoughtful gift that shows you care without overspending. That said, the best gift depends on your relationship and the occasion, not just the price tag.

How did you choose these magic: the gathering gifts?

Our editorial team researched and evaluated products based on customer reviews, ratings, price-to-value ratio, and real-world suitability. Each item was reviewed by Marie Johnson and fact-checked by Will Miller. We only recommend products we'd genuinely gift ourselves.

Why trust this guide?

We researched 28 products for this guide. Each item was evaluated on price-to-value ratio, real buyer feedback, and actual giftability โ€” not just specs and marketing copy. We filtered for products that people genuinely enjoy receiving, not just buying.

28 products evaluated
5 categories covered

Written by Marie Johnson, reviewed by Will Miller. Our recommendations are editorially independent โ€” we earn a small commission from Amazon at no cost to you. Learn how we work.