25 Best St. Nicholas Day Gifts to Fill Their Shoes
St. Nicholas Day gifts for December 6: gold chocolate coins, Dutch chocolate letters, speculaas cookies, chocolate oranges, saint stories and small toys.
On the night of December 5, children across Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium, Poland and plenty of American households leave their shoes or boots by the door. By morning on December 6, St. Nicholas has filled them. The custom honors the fourth-century bishop of Myra who, legend says, tossed bags of gold through a poor family's window, and it is the gentle, small-scale ancestor of Santa Claus.
Because the gifts have to fit in a shoe, the tradition rewards small, thoughtful things: gold chocolate coins, an orange, a candy cane shaped like the bishop's crozier, spiced cookies and perhaps one little toy or a book about the saint himself. We chose every item here with that tradition in mind, mixing classic European treats with kid-friendly extras, cozy socks and a few lasting keepsakes, all with current Amazon prices and most under $25.
Editor's Top Picks
The best gifts for st nicholas day
Hand-picked by our editorial team from 25 options we researched.

Buyer's Guide
How to pick the best st. nicholas day gifts
Start with the classics. Gold coins, an orange and a candy cane are the heart of the tradition, each with a story you can tell: the bags of gold, the gift of rare winter fruit, and the bishop's staff. The chocolate coins and Terry's oranges cover two of the three in one go.
Think shoe-sized. St. Nicholas Day is not a second Christmas. Pick items that fit in a child's boot, such as a chocolate letter, mini puzzles, mittens or a sticker book, and save the big gifts for December 25.
Lean into heritage. If your family has Dutch roots, the chocolate initial and speculaas are what Sinterklaas brings. German families will recognize Lebkuchen, PfeffernΓΌsse and the candle-driven Christmas pyramid.
Add a story. One of the St. Nicholas books helps children understand who the saint was and why he is linked to secret giving. It is also a good gift for godchildren and Sunday school classes.
Plan for a crowd. Several picks come in multipacks (100 coins, 12 puzzles, 24 nutcrackers), which makes it easy to fill every shoe in a large family or a classroom without spending much.
Shop by Budget
Our best pick at every price point
Traditional St. Nicholas Day Treats
Gold coins, oranges, candy canes and chocolate letters: the treats St. Nicholas has left in shoes for generations.
Our top pick because these coins were made for the feast: the colorful foils carry St. Nicholas designs and blessings rather than generic money prints. A pound bag of Belgian chocolate fills a whole family's shoes and gives you a natural moment to tell the story of the bags of gold.
Why Foiled Again St. Nicholas Day Chocolate Coins makes a traditional gift:
- βDesigned for St. Nicholas Day
- βBelgian milk chocolate
- βAbout 80 large 1.5-inch coins
- βResealable bag
The budget way to honor the gold-coin legend. A hundred shiny coins means every child, cousin and classmate can find a handful in their shoe on the morning of December 6.
Why Gold Chocolate Coins, 100 Pack makes a golden gift:
- β100 coins per bag
- βGold foil wrapping
- βEnough for a whole family
- βUnder $25
An orange in the toe of the shoe is one of the oldest St. Nicholas customs. A chocolate orange keeps the symbolism and makes kids far happier, and a twelve-pack covers a large family with spares for teachers.
Why Terry's Milk Chocolate Oranges, 12 Pack makes a classic gift:
- β12 full-size oranges
- βSegmented to share
- βNods to the orange tradition
- βHoliday classic
Candy canes are often said to echo the shepherd's crook St. Nicholas carried as a bishop. These minis are individually wrapped and small enough to tuck several into each shoe.
Why Brach's Mini Peppermint Candy Canes makes a festive gift:
- β260 mini canes
- βIndividually wrapped
- βClassic peppermint
- βUnder $15
In the Netherlands, finding your initial in solid chocolate is part of the Sinterklaas celebration. Order one letter per child for a personalized treat that families with Dutch roots will recognize instantly.
Why De Heer Dutch Chocolate Letter makes a personal gift:
- βImported Dutch chocolate
- βAvailable in every letter
- β2.25 oz size
- βClassic Sinterklaas gift
A treat for after the shoes are emptied. Drop one in hot milk on the evening of December 6 and the marshmallows burst out, a warm end to the feast day for kids and adults alike.
Why Hot Chocolate Bombs, 3 Pack makes a cozy gift:
- βThree bombs
- βMarshmallow centers
- βIndividually wrapped
- βGift box
Books About the Real Saint Nicholas
Stories and devotions that explain who St. Nicholas was and why we celebrate him.
Twelve illustrated legends show children that the real St. Nicholas gave in secret and cared for the poor. The activity ideas make it a good read-aloud for the evening of December 5, before the shoes go out.
Why The Captivating Story of Saint Nicholas makes a inspiring gift:
- β12 illustrated legends
- βActivity ideas included
- βChristian perspective
- βGood for family reading
For older kids and adults who want the history, this short book traces how a bishop from Myra became Santa Claus. It is a thoughtful shoe gift for a teen or a godparent.
Why Saint Nicholas the Giftgiver makes a insightful gift:
- βHistory and legends
- βExplains the Santa connection
- βShort, readable chapters
- βUnder $15
St. Nicholas Day falls in the first week of Advent, so a family devotional is a fitting gift. Lift-the-flap pages keep little hands busy while you read one devotion a day through Christmas.
Why The Biggest Story Advent Lift-the-Flap Book makes a family-friendly gift:
- β25 daily devotions
- βLift-the-flap pages
- βMade for families
- βSturdy for kids
St. Nicholas Keepsakes and Old-World Decorations
Icons, nutcrackers and a Christmas pyramid that come out every December.
Our keepsake pick. The candle-driven pyramid comes from the same German Advent tradition as St. Nicholas Day, and children love watching the scene turn as the candles warm the blades. Unpack it on December 6 and it becomes part of every December after.
Why German-Style Wooden Christmas Pyramid makes a enchanting gift:
- β14 inches tall
- βTwo-tier carousel
- βTurned by candle heat
- βHolds three candles
Painted wooden soldiers in the old German style, small enough to stand in a shoe. Give each child one on St. Nicholas morning and let them hang it on the tree that weekend.
Why Wooden Nutcracker Ornaments, 24 Pack makes a traditional gift:
- β24 ornaments
- βTwo sizes, 4.3 and 5.1 inch
- βHang or stand
- βTraditional painted look
A small icon of St. Nicholas the Wonderworker that hangs from a tree branch or a car mirror. A meaningful feast-day gift for a godchild or a Sunday school class.
Why Saint Nicholas Mini Icon Shrine Ornament makes a devotional gift:
- β3-inch wooden shrine
- βHangs on tree or mirror
- βCrystal-accented icon
- βUnder $20
A handmade Greek icon on aged wood, a beautiful gift for someone named Nicholas or Nicole on their name day, which Orthodox and Catholic families celebrate on December 6 or 19.
Why Handmade Wooden Icon of Saint Nicholas makes a lasting gift:
- βHandmade in Greece
- βSolid wood, 15 x 11 cm
- βWater and sun resistant finish
- βFreestanding or wall hanging
Small St. Nicholas Day Gifts for Kids
Shoe-sized toys, crafts and games to go alongside the sweets.
Small puzzles that slip into a boot alongside the sweets. A twelve-pack stretches across siblings or a whole classroom celebration of St. Nicholas Day.
Why Christmas Mini Jigsaw Puzzles, 12 Pack makes a shoe-sized gift:
- β12 mini puzzles
- βChristmas designs
- βEasy for beginners
- βGood for classroom shoes
A quiet activity for St. Nicholas morning before school. Three hundred holiday stickers and coloring pages fit easily in a shoe and keep younger children busy well into Advent.
Why Cupkin Christmas Sticker Book makes a engaging gift:
- β300+ stickers
- β8 coloring pages
- βLay-flat binding
- βUnder $15
Babies and toddlers cannot eat the chocolate coins yet, so a soft musical Rudolph makes a better first St. Nicholas gift. It is small enough to sit inside a pair of little boots.
Why Musical Rudolph Plush, 8 Inch makes a sweet gift:
- βPlays music
- βSoft 8-inch plush
- βClassic Rudolph design
- βUnder $20
Leave one or two ornaments in each shoe and paint the rest together that afternoon. It turns St. Nicholas Day into a family craft that ends with homemade decorations for the tree.
Why Paintable Wooden Christmas Ornaments makes a creative gift:
- β45 ornaments, 9 designs
- βPredrilled for hanging
- βSmooth unfinished wood
- βIncludes a tray
A family game for the evening of December 6, with questions that kids and grown-ups can both answer. A good choice for households with older children who have outgrown toys in their shoes.
Why Yule Never Guess Christmas Trivia Game makes a lively gift:
- βHoliday trivia for all ages
- βScannable answer codes
- βFast to learn
- βGreat host gift
Cozy Socks and Mittens for December 6
Warm, practical extras that fit neatly inside a boot by the door.
New socks inside a shoe is a fitting, practical St. Nicholas surprise. These merino blend pairs keep feet warm in winter boots, and six pairs last the whole season.
Why Kids Merino Wool Socks, 6 Pairs makes a warm gift:
- βSix pairs
- βMerino wool blend
- βThermal cushioned weave
- βKid and toddler sizes
Adults set out shoes too in many families. Tuck one fluffy pair into Mom's or Grandma's slipper and save the rest for the weeks before Christmas.
Why Fuzzy Cozy Socks for Women, 6 Pairs makes a soft gift:
- βSix pairs
- βUltra-soft fuzzy knit
- βAssorted colors
- βUnder $15
Red, green and white mittens sized for small hands, and small enough to fold into a toddler's boot. A sweet, useful gift under $10 for the youngest in the family.
Why Toddler Knitted Winter Mittens makes a cheerful gift:
- βHoliday colors
- βKnitted and warm
- βOne size for little hands
- βUnder $10
A good St. Nicholas morning is about small surprises and an old story, not big boxes. Mix one traditional treat, one little extra and, if you like, a book about the saint, and the shoes by the door will be the highlight of early December. For the rest of the season, the guides below pick up where St. Nicholas leaves off.
Planning the rest of the season? See our Christmas gifts guide, stocking stuffers and 12 days of Christmas gifts. For more sweet ideas, browse chocolate gifts, or shop Christmas gifts for boys and Christmas gifts for girls.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best st. nicholas day gifts?
Our top picks include Foiled Again St. Nicholas Day Chocolate Coins, Old Mill Windmill Speculaas Cookies, German-Style Wooden Christmas Pyramid. We evaluated 25 products across categories like Traditional Shoe Treats, European Cookies and Sweets, Books About Saint Nicholas.
How much should I spend on st. nicholas day gifts?
Gifts in our guide range from $8.99 to $62.48. We recommend budgeting $30β$75 for a thoughtful gift that shows you care without overspending. That said, the best gift depends on your relationship and the occasion, not just the price tag.
How did you choose these st. nicholas day gifts?
Our editorial team researched and evaluated products based on customer reviews, ratings, price-to-value ratio, and real-world suitability. Each item was reviewed by Marie Johnson and fact-checked by Will Miller. We only recommend products we'd genuinely gift ourselves.
Why trust this guide?
We researched 25 products for this guide. Each item was evaluated on price-to-value ratio, real buyer feedback, and actual giftability β not just specs and marketing copy. We filtered for products that people genuinely enjoy receiving, not just buying.
Written by Marie Johnson, reviewed by Will Miller. Our recommendations are editorially independent β we earn a small commission from Amazon at no cost to you. Learn how we work.























